Friday, January 8, 2016

[stateofmygame] FNM #1

I attended my first Modern FNM of 2016 today. I was looking forward to it all week, having played very little Magic over the Christmas holidays. And what with the goals that I made for myself, I was eager to set it all in motion and get back on that train.

The Deck

After somewhat of a short hiatus from the game, I wasn't sure if I had lost touch with my deck (G/W Hatebears, or Death & Taxes), much less the Modern format as a whole. The recent appearance of the B/x Eldrazi deck caught me totally off guard, and though it's not the first time I'd witnessed the rise of a new archetype, for the first time a little bit of me felt like an old man watching the world pass him by. Perhaps it wasn't so severe (though I do very much have my thoughts/fears of that Eldrazi deck, and what it might imply for the Modern format moving forward).

In any case, other than that, especially after some catch-up reading, I had some relative confidence in my knowledge of the format. Prior to the holidays, I had been playing a G/W Death & Taxes style build that featured Flickerwisp and two Restoration Angels along with some of the goodies provided by the Green splash. That was up until I witnessed Craig Wescoe take Top 4 at GP Pittsburgh with a more "Hatebears" style of the deck, with Loxodon Smiter, Voice of Resurgence and Wilt-Leaf Liege instead of the aforementioned.

Admittedly, once you add a second colour into the deck, the deck suddenly has a broad spectrum of possible builds - from more intricate flicker-heavy decks that run Flickerwisps, Restoration Angels, Blade Splicers, etc, to "Hatebear"-style beatdown decks, to Vial-less decks that instead rely on Collected Company, and everything in between. By now I like to think that I have a fair bit of experience in the various builds, and some ideas of their strengths and weaknesses. For example, Aether Vial is a powerful pillar of the deck, and to not play it in favour of CoCo, it begs the question "why not just play Abzan CoCo"? Or why not play Abzan Aggro (which some people refer to simply as G/W Aggro)? It runs all the same goodies like Voice of Resurgence and Loxodon Smiter, but with the bonus of hand disruption and Lingering Souls (now there's a card!). 

I am a firm believer of having a very strong idea of your deck's identity, and if it ever becomes clear that your deck is just a "worse version of another deck", then it's time to move on. In this way, I find it very useful and refreshing to always be asking if the version of the deck I'm playing is the best version of the deck I could be playing. This extends to considering a much broader range of D&T archetypes, including all the other possible colour splashes. And obviously, that's not an easy question answer concretely at all. But like all things, simply being aware that the question exists is much better than otherwise.

With that, I was faced with a major choice - the Flickerwisp version? Or the "Hatebears" version? Surely, each has its strong suits, but what's better equipped for the format? On one hand, I have the most experience and success playing with the Flickerwisps, which are unfathomably flexible and powerful in conjunction with Aether Vial. On the other hand, I had just come off my first GP experience having watched Craig Wescoe make Top 4 with zero Flickerwisps. I had his list (or something very close to it) sleeved up, but didn't have as much experience with it. So what to go with?

Without going into all of my thoughts about the differences and pros/cons of the two versions of the deck (though I could), though each has seen its share of success (see here: SCG Open 17th place), I will make one comment - though the decks look quite similar, there's a subtle difference in skillset required to play the decks well. Flickerwisp lends itself to more options, more versatility, and more tricks. Playing the deck makes you feel clever. So in that way, the deck is maximized in the hands of someone who can see all the possibilities with the cards available to them. On the other hand, less versatility is available to the "Hatebears" version of the deck. Instead of tricks, you have bulkier creatures in the form of Smiters and Wilt-Leaf Liege. Both are quite powerful, and provide you with a bigger army. And as such, it's more crucial to identify the pace of the game, and how to shift it in your favour by initiating races and making favourable attacks. (I don't think I explained this very well).

In any case, I went with a list very similar to Craig Wescoe's suggested list. The sideboard is a bit different, and there are a few singular differences in the maindeck. I won't post the exact list here - I'd hopefully like to have a more detailed discussion of the decklist another time.

The Experience

Overall, I went 3-2 and placed 8th out of.. 20+ people? Not the greatest result, I'd say. Especially when I know that I could have done better.

And that's good, after all, isn't it? Knowing very well that you could have done better, as well as how you could have done better - that's valuable. Obviously I'd like to be at a point where I can perform well, and perform consistently, each lesson is a step of the journey, and I'm well on my way.

Now, to be specific, it went something like this.

In the very first match, I played against Grixis Control (the Blue Jund variant). The very first game of that match went by in a blur. It was one of those games where I felt like I wasn't in control - like I was just going along with what was happening, nodding my head to the opponents' plays, and playing cards from my hand simply because I can. I know, and knew, that that is not how I should be playing the game of Magic. I've been in that state before, and though I'm not quite sure how to describe it, it's something of a mix of passiveness, lethargy and general lack of focus. Even with the same cards in your hand, playing the game focused and being in control, feeling like you can and will make the decisions to alter the course of the game in your favour, is a much different game than the one I played.

Perhaps it was just rust, after a period of not playing the game. I didn't know how I expected the game to go - which is something I feel is important in Constructed. For example, if I am aware that I am playing against Grixis, I (should) know how a winning game should unfold, and same with a losing one.

I told myself to focus, and I won the next two games, and the match. I could have easily not won, but I was glad with the way I pulled myself together and executed. It felt sluggish, like it took more mental energy than it should have, but it was what it was. I even made a serious blunder at the end of Game 3, which luckily did not cost me the game.

I won my second match, against someone playing Affinity. I can't say that his skill level was among the higher/highest at the store, but the deck itself is inherently powerful. For whatever reasons, I managed to win the match and was feeling quite pleased with myself.

Match 3, I see a Temple Garden and then a Hallowed Fountain, and I wonder if I'm playing against Knightfall. And I am. I am able to grind out a creature-based war in Game 1 - sweet. I lose to the combo in Game 2, and we move to Game 3. Here, I make a serious blunder, or a series of serious blunders, or something of the sort.

I am on the play. He plays a Stirring Wildwood as his first land, so I'm already ahead. At some point, he has a Knight of the Reliquary on the board (so he could win next turn), and passes to me. I have 4 mana total available (2 lands and 2 Noble Hierarchs), a Qasali Pridemage, and a Vial on two. In my hand are is an Aven Mindcensor, a second Qasali, and a Wilt-Leaf Liege. At this point there's 5 minutes left. And I lose my head.

Perhaps it's because he had been urging me to play more quickly. That certainly got to me. Perhaps it's because I got it in my head that I needed to race him, when a calmer Zimu would have realized that the game at that point was in the bag. I just needed to play patiently, but play physically quickly. All I needed to do was be the aggressor, but hold up answers in case he combo'ed off - which is technically impossible if I held up mana/Vial for my Qasali's and Mindcensor. Instead, I tap out for the Wilt-Leaf, Vial in the second Qasali, and go for the race. To be somewhat fair, if he didn't have the combo I would've (virtually) won the next turn. Guess what? He untapped and slammed Retreat to Coralhelm. Game over.

I kicked myself for a good while. Sometimes a player kicks himself over losing. Sometimes it's meaningful, other times not. Here, I think it definitely was. Though I can meaninglessly claim that it was the first time I'd played the match, that would be a lame excuse. I've read about the deck, I know how it works. All it really was was a quick lapse in judgment. In the crucial moment, that's all it took for things to go wrong. That's lesson number 1: 1a) knowing that you have to stay focused, and 1b) actually doing it.

So that was the first major take-away. 

After losing this match, I was honestly a little shook, and lost the next match to Affinity. Which is fine, Affinity is not a great matchup for the most part. But it did lead me to my second major take-away: you can only win more by continuing to win. Sounds silly or obvious, I know. But it's like the common Chinese proverb that goes something along the lines of "once you start slipping, it's easy to continue slipping". In Magic, winning matches builds confidence, which sets you up to continue winning matches until you win big. But if you lose, it chips away at your mental fortitude - or it can. Surely a strong and experienced player will more easily shrug off the loss to not let it get in their way of getting back on a winning track going forward. Obviously it's not really useful to conclude that you just "gotta keep winning". But I do feel that it contributes to the overall idea of what it takes to win consistently (especially in a long event). Because if you know how it's supposed to feel, then you can more easily go after it.

That's all I really wanted to talk about. We all want to improve and be good at this game (though different people want this to different degrees, sure). And while grinding and practice certainly gets you there, I want to be more analytical, so that I can distill the important lessons and improve quickly. The search to becoming a better player is also a search for how to become a better player. And today was a good lesson in that.

Cheers,
Zimu





No comments: