Sunday, June 26, 2016

[tournament report] GPT Indianapolis

It seems that any claims I make to take my MTG journaling/writing to the next level always end in naught. Perhaps they're simply too ambitious for me right now - perhaps in the (near?) future when I develop a better sense of daily routine. For now, I'm going to keep it short and minimalist.

- - -

Tournament: Grand Prix Trial - Indianapolis
Deck: B/W Eldrazi & Taxes (list here)
Place: 1st (via top 4 split)
Store: The Enchanted Badger (Ithaca)
Attendance: 19

Round 1: BYE 
Got the bye - what luck! I sat by myself and drew some sample hands. They were quite miserable.

Round 2: Tron (Patrick) 2-1
Game 1: On the draw, I play a turn 2 Thought-Knot Seer, followed by more hand disruption. I took away all his threats, but didn't restrict his mana development. I get him to 5 before he activates an Oblivion Stone to clear the board. He plays a second O-Stone, while I play a Tidehollow Sculler, taking nothing, and pass the turn, holding Restoration Angel and Path to Exile in hand. On his turn, he opts for the greedy play and taps out to play Ulamog instead of holding mana open to activate the second O-stone if need be, exiling my two Eldrazi Temples instead of coloured mana or my creature. I play Resto Angel at the end of his turn, untap, Path his Ulamog and attack for exactly lethal.
Game 2: I mulligan a hand with Ghost Quarter, Aether Vial, Thalia, and numerous threats. In retrospect, I regret mulliganing that hand. He keeps after one mulligan, while I mulligan a second time. He's on the play and manages to stick a Karn. I'm not able to assemble the mana to play Anguished Unmaking on the Karn.
Game 3: On the play, I start with a turn 2 Leonin Arbiter into turn 3 Thalia, with him playing an Expedition on his first turn. One Ghost Quarter (read: Strip Mine) sets him back while I chip away with the hatebears. He continues struggling to dig for mana or Pyroclasms. With him at 10 life, I play a Restoration Angel at the end of his turn, untap and play Zealous Persecution to attack for exactly lethal (I boarded it in to fight sweepers).

Round 3: Affinity (James) 1-2
Game 1: On the play. I believe this game started off okay for me, but even with some hand disruption, I don't have sufficient removal and lose to Signal Pests and co.
Game 2: On the play again, I play a turn 2 Sculler into turn 3 Wasteland Strangler, and coast to victory with Eldrazi Displacer on board.
Game 3: I keep a strong hand.. against the wrong half of his deck. Being on the draw against a turn 2 Master of Etherium banking on Stony Silence and Anguished Unmaking is no bueno.

Round 4: Mardu Tokens (Tommy) 2-0
Game 1: On the play, I get Inquisition of Kozilek'ed twice in a row, but he stumbles on lands, and is constrained by Thalia and Leonin Arbiter. In subsequent turns, Sculler and Thought-Knot seer take away his low-costing plays, while we trade some removal (on a Confidant and Pyromancer). He eventually plays Ajani (-2) followed by Lingering Souls, but the tokens get cleared by Eldrazi Displacer, and he loses Ajani and the game.
Game 2: He plays a turn 2 Confidant with a couple of removal spells which deal with some of my early threats. Unfortunately for him, he goes at least 4 turns without flipping a land (though he does get two Inquisitions). He takes a fair bit of life loss from the Confidant, but opts not to block with it, as he's desperate for a third land (probably the right play). Meanwhile, my board develops and it's too late for him. In his hand were three Lingering Souls and two Liliana's. 

Round 5: UWR Control (James) 0-0-3
We intentionally draw to lock up Top 8.

I get 4th seed in the top 8, with the following matchups: 
UWR Control (1) vs Merfolk (8)
Affinity (2) vs Mardu Tokens (7)
Merfolk (3) vs Grixis Tokens (6)
Eldrazi & Taxes (4) vs Bant Eldrazi (5)

Top 8: Bant Eldrazi (Quinn) 2-1
Game 1: On the play, I start with a turn 1 Vial into turn 2 Relic of Progenitus and Shambling Vent. Meanwhile, his first couple of plays are Noble Hierarch and Birds of Paradise. The Relic exiles numerous cards, thanks to him cracking a fetchland on his first turn, and playing Ancient Stirrings, etc. As a result, I get to play a turn 3 Wasteland Strangler, killing his Hierarch, setting him back a turn. (The next turn or two are a bit fuzzy) but I vial in a Eldrazi Displacer and flicker the Strangler to kill the bird. This gives me a crucial turn where I stick a Thought-Knot Seer, taking his Thought-Knot Seer (revealing 3 Reality Smashers in his hand as well). Eventually, I have TKS, Displacer and Strangler on the board with plenty of mana, and the game is locked up. 
Game 2: I keep a decent hand with plenty of threats that synergize well, but he keeps a hand with Matter Reshaper, three Path to Exiles and a Dismember. I don't manage to stick any threats. Even though he won this game, I noticed that he missed both the enter the battlefield trigger as well as the exit the battlefield trigger on his Thragtusk.
Game 3: I open the same way as game 1, with a turn 1 Vial and turn 2 Relic (though with no early exiles, I crack it to dig to get ahead) and Shambling Vent. He plays Ancient Stirrings into land drops and plays a turn 3 Displacer, followed by a Noble Hierarch, which I killed with a Vial'ed-in Pontiff. On my fourth turn, I play a TKS and take his TKS (being on the play helped here). It comes down to a crucial turn where he's at 11 with an Eldrazi Displacer on board, and plays Ancient Stirrings to get TKS. In my hand is Anguished Unmaking. Since the TKS would have to come next turn, I decide to unmake the displacer at end of turn, and attack for 7 with my TKS, Pontiff, and Shambling Vent, putting him to 4. I pass the turn, he has to crack a fetch to play his TKS, allowing me to attack for exactly lethal.

At this point I ask if anyone in the top 4 was interested in the bye's, which no one was. I suggested splitting the prize evenly among the 2nd, 3rd and 4th place players, with the 1st place player taking less prize and the bye's. They agreed, and I "took" first place. We decided to play top 4 for fun.

Top 4: Merfolk (Michael) 2-0 ?
Game 1: I'm on the play. We both have turn 1 Aether Vial, with me playing a turn 2 Displacer off Eldrazi Temple. He spends turn 2 playing Spreading Seas on the Temple, which I get rid of with Flickerwisp. With my Vial on 3, I very quickly get to a point where I have Flickerwisp, Displacer and Thought-Knot Seer on board with plenty of mana. I blink my Flickerwisp to reset his Vial, lock him out of combat, and take the game.
Game 2: It goes similarly to game 1, although is much closer due to a more explosive opening on his part. But at one point I have a Vial on 3, and a Displacer and TKS in play. He attacks with 6 creatures for massive damage. I Vial in a Flickerwisp, blink it twice, exiling his two lords until end of turn, and block and kill 2 of the creatures. In retrospect I could have taken better advantage of that opportunity, but it was a game for fun and I had loosened up at that point. Either way, I eventually work my way to locking the game up on board.

On the flipside, Mardu Tokens beat Merfolk in their "for-fun" game. Having beat him in the Swiss, I felt somewhat confident of my chances of winning had we not split (though I was somewhat surprised with my win over Merfolk).

Monday, March 21, 2016

[GPbound] - Introduction

In the last few months months, I have become increasingly proficient with what has been my Modern deck of choice for almost a year now - G/W Hatebears (I could also call it G/W Death & Taxes, not a stickler for differentiating between the two - though there are clear differences, they lie on a continuous spectrum of deck concepts). I have also been able to achieve a relatively consistent level of success piloting it in more competitive REL's, winning two GP Trials, Top 4'ing two more, going 6-3 in my first GP (Pittsburgh), and doing generally well at local events.

Most recently, I played in a GPT for GP Charlotte (May 20-22) for the sake of competition, and was fortunate to come away with the two bye's. I already had some thoughts about playing in larger events this summer, but this win certainly incentivized me to try to play for a higher level of success at an upcoming Modern GP. (Unfortunately GP LA is the same weekend and same format, for which I don't have any byes. I am still deciding between going to LA for the sake of seeing friends, or to Charlotte for the sake of competitive success). Either way, I have committed to preparing for an upcoming Modern GP to the best of my ability, and this series of blog posts will document the whole process!

Some introspective personal thoughts about Magic in my life: 

Being a graduate student with lots of work responsibilities, but also being a graduate student with less-than-ideal work ethic, Magic has been somewhat of an anchor for me. While I'm otherwise prone to procrastination and distraction, I'm motivated and completely focused when I play Magic. I care about the game and enjoy it on an intellectual level, and have a genuine love for the game. But being a graduate student in what should be an important juncture in my life, I often wonder about the course of my life. Where am I headed? What do I want to do with my life? What are the things that matter most to me? I'm thankful that my time in Ithaca has so far been fruitful, at least in terms of self-discovery. All this begs the question of where Magic fits in my life - past, present and future. 

Everybody has their hobbies, their passions. Having been raised as an only child in a family of Chinese academics, I think I have some ways to go in terms of acquiring a healthy and balanced outlook on life - work/life balance, shall we say. For this reason, and others, I think Magic represents more than just a hobby to me. As much as I enjoy it, it also represents a challenge for me to fit into my life in a balanced and fruitful way. I'm not going to give up hobbies that I enjoy, but if I'm going to do something, even something like Magic, I want to be as productive as possible in it. I have also heard of numerous anecdotes of PhD students at MIT who had a passion for Magic and similar games, who temporarily dropped out of their studies to create Prismata, an online turn-based card game. While that particular story is somewhat extreme, it still raises to me the questions of whether I can and/or will build my life and career in a way that accommodates for these passions (I'm hesitant to call them passions, though), and how. 

In any case, the point of all this was to shed some light on the role of Magic in my life, and my motivations.

Until next time!


Monday, February 29, 2016

[stateofmygame] SCG Philly

This past weekend was SCG Philadelphia. I went with James, Matt and Daniel. Up until the date, I wasn't 100% sure if it was a good idea for me to go. But I did, and it was a lot of fun - a much needed getaway. To give a brief break-down of my take-aways from the weekend, I'll write this post in point-form, in the style of LSV.


  • The main event was Legacy, which I do not yet have a deck for (other than Manaless Dredge, but it has no sideboard and I have no experience). James and Matt played, while Daniel and I played in side events (Modern for me and Limited for him).
  • On Saturday, all the really competitive players were probably playing Legacy, so although everyone came prepared to face (and lose to) Eldrazi, it was nowhere to be found in the Modern Challenges. This was quite the opposite on Sunday, where many of the Legacy players who had dropped from the main event played in the Modern Classic. Among them was Todd Stevens, who was playing U/W Eldrazi for the first time (who also beat me 2-0).
  • I went 3-1 in the Modern Challenge on Saturday, going 2-0 against G/W Aggro, 0-2 against Esper Control, 2-0 against Tron, and 2-1 against Ad Nauseum. This got me 120 prize wall tickets, which was converted to $25 store credit at SCG and 2 packs.
  • I went 3-3 in the Modern Classic on Sunday. I started 0-1 and went up to 3-1 before losing two more to drop at 3-3. I went 1-2 against B/W Tokens, 2-1 against Jund, 2-0 against Tron, 2-1 against Naya Company, 0-2 against U/W Eldrazi (Todd Stevens), and 1-2 against Merfolk. 
  • I had made predictions that I was likely to run into Merfolk, which I did. I packed 2 Hushwing Gryff's in my 75 for Eldrazi, Company/Chord decks and Fish, but unfortunately never saw them. Still, it was gratifying to see that I had a good intuition on the format and wasn't surprised by anything.
  • Playing in both events provided a lot of learning experiences, with the Classic having taught me more than the Challenge, by nature of the difference in the two events. 
  • One general thing that I did not expect to get to me was the event as a whole - there was a lot going on, lots of people, lots of noise. It wasn't always easy to get myself to calm down, drown out the hustle and bustle and mentally focus on the match at hand. This is obviously an important skill at large events, and is something I need to be more aware of.
  • One thing that I was particularly proud of myself for was my improved ability to stay positive and show a lot of poise when I would lose the first game of the match. There were definitely matches where I came back to win 2-1 after losing the first game, and even in the unfavored matchups, I was able to make a close match out of it, where I might have given up and folded months ago.
  • It was incredible playing against higher caliber players - most notably Todd Stevens. It was my first time playing against a "pro". But what struck me was how light-hearted and friendly he was, all the while remaining focused and playing tightly. I made a crucial misplay (or more, probably) that prevented me from possibly taken a game, or even match from him.
  • I did some trading, some selling and some buying, which was fun. I bought two Bayou's from SCG for $100 each, and later sold a bunch of my current collection (including a lot of bulk rares) for $175 in SCG store credit. In retrospect I should have done the selling first and buying later - oh well. It was nice to get rid of a big part of my unwanted/unneeded cards though.
  • Philly was awesome. It seemed like a great city. I was fortunate to have been there when the weather was favourable. Unfortunately I didn't get to explore the city very much at all, since I spent most of my time at the convention center. But the architecture was interesting, the streets were vibrant, and the food was really good! I'd definitely like to go back again in the future, for Magic or not.
  • Having had to wake up early for the events, I went from a recent streak of sleeping at absurd hours (5~6 AM) until the afternoon to sleeping at midnight and waking up at 7:30. That was a nice change.
  • I got a custom Voice of Resurgence Token from Aaron Miller, along with a plethora of signed tokens. With this, along with my having recently received custom tokens from Johannes Voss, I now have way more awesome tokens than I get to use.
  • I got to playtest a bit of Legacy in the hotel room with my Manaless Dredge deck and James' Lands deck. I have to admit, Legacy is as great a format as I thought it would be. I relish the thought of being able to play Aggro Loam in it (not so) soon.
  • Overall, it was a great weekend! Good times, good food, good laughs. I am really enjoying every trip I make to play Magic, whether it be a long or short trip. More to come!
Cheers!

Thursday, January 28, 2016

[stateofmygame] Recent events

Recent Events 

The last couple of times I wrote here, I had made some resolutions for 2016, and followed it up with my first FNM of the year. Since then, I attended two Oath of the Gatewatch prereleases (one of which was Two-Headed Giant with Daniel), one Modern FNM and one Modern Tournament at Mythic Games in Elmira. I skipped out on the FNM on the weekend of the prereleases to go to a karaoke place with some classmates/friends. It was super duper fun.

I went 4-1 at the Saturday prerelease, opening what appeared to be a very mediocre pool. After getting crushed playtesting with the person sitting across from me before Round 1 began, I changed the deck from Black/Blue to White/Blue, which turned out to be a great move. The Black creatures were all great, but without sufficient colourless mana-fixing in my pool, they were no better than overcosted vanilla creatures. Overall, my deck's power level wasn't high, but it was lean and quick, which got the job done. As for the 2HG Prerelease, Daniel and I went 2-2-1 to finished 10th overall. Our first match ended on a very sour note, against a pair of opponents who played slow decks (life-gaining weenies) and played slowly. They also pounced at the revelation that 2HG only has 3 extra turns after time instead of 5. Oh well. It was still a fun time - my first time playing 2HG, and we had dinner with Daniel's good friend Haofei and his wife (to whom we lost in the final round of the day). 

The following Friday, I went 4-1 at FNM to take second place (losing round 3 to Haofei, who was playing R/G Tron of all things!). Despite my relative success at other competitive events, this is the best I've done to date at the Badger. Without going too much into the details, it was a great experience. I would say that every success is a great learning experience, as it familiarizes you with how winning consistently feels and what it takes, but that goes contrary to what some would say, that failing is the best teaching experience. I will, however, make a note of two of the more memorable matches. The first was against Jund (a highly anticipated? rematch between me and Aydin). After handily losing Game 1, I solidly won Game 2. In Game 3, I won the game with no lands, having suffered from two Fulminator Mages, off the back of an Aether Vial and two Noble Hierarchs. The other Match was against Adrian, who recently started playing Mono-White Death & Taxes. I've played very little mirror-matches (even pseudo-mirrors like this), but my experience helped tremendously. I learned a lot from the match alone about the dynamics of the match-up, which warrants going into in the future.

The last event since then was a Modern event in Elmira, which was brought to our attention by James. With a $25 entry fee, the event held a sizable prize pool, and made for an enticing event at a higher competitive level for me to test my abilities. Fresh off my 4-1 FNM run from the previous night, I traveled with Peter to the event that Saturday morning. Long story short, I went 3-0 in my first three rounds before intentionally drawing twice to get into the Top 8. Fortunately/unfortunately, once the Top 8 was determined, the players agreed to split the prize pool, so I put my 80+ dollar prize towards a OGW booster box (I had to pay the difference out of my own pocket, but that's okay), and we went home. Obviously I'm not sure what would've happened if we played out the Top 8, but I felt pretty good about my day. I had an incredibly lucky topdeck to win Game 1 against an Infect player, and I won against Anderson, a R/G Tron player from Syracuse who I had beaten in my GPT win a while back.

Anyway, those are just a brief update of my recent events, which are nowhere near as valuable as my take-aways and thoughts going forward. That'll come in the next installment, where I hope to talk about my thoughts on the Modern metagame, how my deck is positioned, its matchups, as well as my growth as a player.

Cheers!

Friday, January 8, 2016

[stateofmygame] FNM #1

I attended my first Modern FNM of 2016 today. I was looking forward to it all week, having played very little Magic over the Christmas holidays. And what with the goals that I made for myself, I was eager to set it all in motion and get back on that train.

The Deck

After somewhat of a short hiatus from the game, I wasn't sure if I had lost touch with my deck (G/W Hatebears, or Death & Taxes), much less the Modern format as a whole. The recent appearance of the B/x Eldrazi deck caught me totally off guard, and though it's not the first time I'd witnessed the rise of a new archetype, for the first time a little bit of me felt like an old man watching the world pass him by. Perhaps it wasn't so severe (though I do very much have my thoughts/fears of that Eldrazi deck, and what it might imply for the Modern format moving forward).

In any case, other than that, especially after some catch-up reading, I had some relative confidence in my knowledge of the format. Prior to the holidays, I had been playing a G/W Death & Taxes style build that featured Flickerwisp and two Restoration Angels along with some of the goodies provided by the Green splash. That was up until I witnessed Craig Wescoe take Top 4 at GP Pittsburgh with a more "Hatebears" style of the deck, with Loxodon Smiter, Voice of Resurgence and Wilt-Leaf Liege instead of the aforementioned.

Admittedly, once you add a second colour into the deck, the deck suddenly has a broad spectrum of possible builds - from more intricate flicker-heavy decks that run Flickerwisps, Restoration Angels, Blade Splicers, etc, to "Hatebear"-style beatdown decks, to Vial-less decks that instead rely on Collected Company, and everything in between. By now I like to think that I have a fair bit of experience in the various builds, and some ideas of their strengths and weaknesses. For example, Aether Vial is a powerful pillar of the deck, and to not play it in favour of CoCo, it begs the question "why not just play Abzan CoCo"? Or why not play Abzan Aggro (which some people refer to simply as G/W Aggro)? It runs all the same goodies like Voice of Resurgence and Loxodon Smiter, but with the bonus of hand disruption and Lingering Souls (now there's a card!). 

I am a firm believer of having a very strong idea of your deck's identity, and if it ever becomes clear that your deck is just a "worse version of another deck", then it's time to move on. In this way, I find it very useful and refreshing to always be asking if the version of the deck I'm playing is the best version of the deck I could be playing. This extends to considering a much broader range of D&T archetypes, including all the other possible colour splashes. And obviously, that's not an easy question answer concretely at all. But like all things, simply being aware that the question exists is much better than otherwise.

With that, I was faced with a major choice - the Flickerwisp version? Or the "Hatebears" version? Surely, each has its strong suits, but what's better equipped for the format? On one hand, I have the most experience and success playing with the Flickerwisps, which are unfathomably flexible and powerful in conjunction with Aether Vial. On the other hand, I had just come off my first GP experience having watched Craig Wescoe make Top 4 with zero Flickerwisps. I had his list (or something very close to it) sleeved up, but didn't have as much experience with it. So what to go with?

Without going into all of my thoughts about the differences and pros/cons of the two versions of the deck (though I could), though each has seen its share of success (see here: SCG Open 17th place), I will make one comment - though the decks look quite similar, there's a subtle difference in skillset required to play the decks well. Flickerwisp lends itself to more options, more versatility, and more tricks. Playing the deck makes you feel clever. So in that way, the deck is maximized in the hands of someone who can see all the possibilities with the cards available to them. On the other hand, less versatility is available to the "Hatebears" version of the deck. Instead of tricks, you have bulkier creatures in the form of Smiters and Wilt-Leaf Liege. Both are quite powerful, and provide you with a bigger army. And as such, it's more crucial to identify the pace of the game, and how to shift it in your favour by initiating races and making favourable attacks. (I don't think I explained this very well).

In any case, I went with a list very similar to Craig Wescoe's suggested list. The sideboard is a bit different, and there are a few singular differences in the maindeck. I won't post the exact list here - I'd hopefully like to have a more detailed discussion of the decklist another time.

The Experience

Overall, I went 3-2 and placed 8th out of.. 20+ people? Not the greatest result, I'd say. Especially when I know that I could have done better.

And that's good, after all, isn't it? Knowing very well that you could have done better, as well as how you could have done better - that's valuable. Obviously I'd like to be at a point where I can perform well, and perform consistently, each lesson is a step of the journey, and I'm well on my way.

Now, to be specific, it went something like this.

In the very first match, I played against Grixis Control (the Blue Jund variant). The very first game of that match went by in a blur. It was one of those games where I felt like I wasn't in control - like I was just going along with what was happening, nodding my head to the opponents' plays, and playing cards from my hand simply because I can. I know, and knew, that that is not how I should be playing the game of Magic. I've been in that state before, and though I'm not quite sure how to describe it, it's something of a mix of passiveness, lethargy and general lack of focus. Even with the same cards in your hand, playing the game focused and being in control, feeling like you can and will make the decisions to alter the course of the game in your favour, is a much different game than the one I played.

Perhaps it was just rust, after a period of not playing the game. I didn't know how I expected the game to go - which is something I feel is important in Constructed. For example, if I am aware that I am playing against Grixis, I (should) know how a winning game should unfold, and same with a losing one.

I told myself to focus, and I won the next two games, and the match. I could have easily not won, but I was glad with the way I pulled myself together and executed. It felt sluggish, like it took more mental energy than it should have, but it was what it was. I even made a serious blunder at the end of Game 3, which luckily did not cost me the game.

I won my second match, against someone playing Affinity. I can't say that his skill level was among the higher/highest at the store, but the deck itself is inherently powerful. For whatever reasons, I managed to win the match and was feeling quite pleased with myself.

Match 3, I see a Temple Garden and then a Hallowed Fountain, and I wonder if I'm playing against Knightfall. And I am. I am able to grind out a creature-based war in Game 1 - sweet. I lose to the combo in Game 2, and we move to Game 3. Here, I make a serious blunder, or a series of serious blunders, or something of the sort.

I am on the play. He plays a Stirring Wildwood as his first land, so I'm already ahead. At some point, he has a Knight of the Reliquary on the board (so he could win next turn), and passes to me. I have 4 mana total available (2 lands and 2 Noble Hierarchs), a Qasali Pridemage, and a Vial on two. In my hand are is an Aven Mindcensor, a second Qasali, and a Wilt-Leaf Liege. At this point there's 5 minutes left. And I lose my head.

Perhaps it's because he had been urging me to play more quickly. That certainly got to me. Perhaps it's because I got it in my head that I needed to race him, when a calmer Zimu would have realized that the game at that point was in the bag. I just needed to play patiently, but play physically quickly. All I needed to do was be the aggressor, but hold up answers in case he combo'ed off - which is technically impossible if I held up mana/Vial for my Qasali's and Mindcensor. Instead, I tap out for the Wilt-Leaf, Vial in the second Qasali, and go for the race. To be somewhat fair, if he didn't have the combo I would've (virtually) won the next turn. Guess what? He untapped and slammed Retreat to Coralhelm. Game over.

I kicked myself for a good while. Sometimes a player kicks himself over losing. Sometimes it's meaningful, other times not. Here, I think it definitely was. Though I can meaninglessly claim that it was the first time I'd played the match, that would be a lame excuse. I've read about the deck, I know how it works. All it really was was a quick lapse in judgment. In the crucial moment, that's all it took for things to go wrong. That's lesson number 1: 1a) knowing that you have to stay focused, and 1b) actually doing it.

So that was the first major take-away. 

After losing this match, I was honestly a little shook, and lost the next match to Affinity. Which is fine, Affinity is not a great matchup for the most part. But it did lead me to my second major take-away: you can only win more by continuing to win. Sounds silly or obvious, I know. But it's like the common Chinese proverb that goes something along the lines of "once you start slipping, it's easy to continue slipping". In Magic, winning matches builds confidence, which sets you up to continue winning matches until you win big. But if you lose, it chips away at your mental fortitude - or it can. Surely a strong and experienced player will more easily shrug off the loss to not let it get in their way of getting back on a winning track going forward. Obviously it's not really useful to conclude that you just "gotta keep winning". But I do feel that it contributes to the overall idea of what it takes to win consistently (especially in a long event). Because if you know how it's supposed to feel, then you can more easily go after it.

That's all I really wanted to talk about. We all want to improve and be good at this game (though different people want this to different degrees, sure). And while grinding and practice certainly gets you there, I want to be more analytical, so that I can distill the important lessons and improve quickly. The search to becoming a better player is also a search for how to become a better player. And today was a good lesson in that.

Cheers,
Zimu





Wednesday, January 6, 2016

[stateofmygame] Thoughts for 2016

The latter third of 2015 was incredibly fruitful for me as a Magic: the Gathering player and enthusiast. I had always enjoyed the game, and in the summer I decided to push myself to play in events. Initially this goal started small - FNM already felt quite formal and competitive for me (as a player who was most familiar with the game in cafeteria lunch table and kitchen table environments, though I played a bit of Standard and Draft at a few FNM's in undergrad). I began going regularly, and as I did so, I looked to set meaningful goals for myself to push myself further. This eventually led to two Grand Prix Trials, from one of which I won myself two bye's for GP Pittsburgh, which prompted me to plan and make the trip to Pittsburgh. Along the way, I made close friends with whom I bonded as well as shared and enjoyed all my experiences with. 

But the New Year has passed, and we are now in 2016. Graduate school struggles have pushed me to reevaluate my habits, and I have spent some time pondering how to structure my time moving forward and to pursue change in myself for the better. Though I won't rant excessively about school stresses here, I still feel more motivated to continue pursuing growth and improvement in the game of Magic. I feel that it's a valuable hobby for me, one that's an intellectual exercise and at the same time takes my mind off everything else. I admit I've felt this way about Magic since middle school (I would spend afternoons after school reading articles off the WotC website and tinkering with my deck). Furthermore, the past year, and the follow years to come, has been a time of self-growth. And one thing that has been at the forefront of my mind are the questions of what do I want from life, and what am I going to do to get it? These are obviously deep questions, questions to which I have little ideas as to how to answer. But one thing I do feel is that I want to preserve, if not further pursue, interests that I feel are important to who I am, despite not being sure where they'll take me, or how I'll manage to integrate them together meaningfully.

With that spiel out of the way, I'd like to talk about some of my thoughts and hopes for myself in this upcoming year of 2016.

  • One major take-away from the past few months has been a steady rise in my self-confidence as a Magic player, particularly in constructed formats. I've always felt that I could be a competent/good MTG player, and my accomplishments have been sort of proof of that (even though they may be fairly minor accomplishments to some): a GPT win, a GPT top 4, a Game Day win, 6-3 at my first GP. 
    • But this begged the questions "just what makes a good MTG player?" and "how do I improve?". So far, I took, and take, pride in playing a beloved deck of mine (Modern Death & Taxes) and have continually developed a deeper understanding of the deck, and its position in the format. So am I a good player in general? Or do I excel with this particular deck? Hopefully some combination of both. 
    • Still, this prompts some possible courses of action on my part, with the first being having the will and interest to try new decks and seeing how I do with them. I admit that even though I talk about having multiple decks of interest, I often cave and fall back into my comfort zone, in an effort to continue winning (even though I don't win as much as I would like at FNM's). I also did try Modern Storm one week, that did not go well at all.
    • The second thing is to try different formats. LSV is a role model in this regard, I admire his knowledge of and feel for the game in general, which really shows in all the formats that he plays. Now, actually doing this is something that's a bit more difficult to do, simply due to time restraints. Between school, FNM's, other hobbies, casual weekend playing and general procrastination, I find it difficult to make, or simply justify making more time for MTG. Still, taking time off from Modern to play in weekly Drafts might prove interesting and beneficial. 
  • Preparation Prevents Poor Performance. This has proven true multiple times, and I would like to improve my ability to effectively prepare for events I plan to enter. To some degree this extends to weekly FNM's - they're worth preparing for from week to week. They also serve as continuous preparation and practice for larger events. For those, I would like to schedule testing time with the crew (Peter, Daniel, etc) to be systematic with play-testing.
  • I'd like to continue setting goals for myself. Admittedly I did not set any real performance targets last year, I more or less just told myself that I would attend higher level events. This was obviously a good start. Moving forward, I'd like to set similar goals for myself:
    • I'd like to attend two GP's this year. Now that I'm in the US, with a car, there'll surely be accessible GP's within a reasonable driving distance (I'm looking at you, GP Detroit).
    • In order to pursue better chances of performing well, I'd like to attend the relevant GP Trials for those events, if possible. 
    • I'd like to play in the Modern events in Elmira (that have recently started, with some hefty monetary prizes) as an intermediate step between FNM's and higher level events.
    • I'd like to go 5-0 at FNM at least once before the summer. I feel like every time I succeed gives me another glimpse into what it's like to succeed and what it takes to succeed. It doesn't matter that FNM is a different environment - metagames vary and I want to know that I can adapt and succeed.
  • I'd like to write regularly about my thoughts about the game - both in terms of my experiences and performances, but my testing and deckbuilding/tuning thoughts as well. I've always claimed myself to be analytical, I've always thought and talked about how I enjoy and want to write and document my thoughts, processes and such. So I'm going to do it. I'm just going to do it.
Happy New Year! 
Zimu

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

[Draft] Two GPT's, One Weekend

Last I wrote, it was about my first Magic, the Gathering experience here in Ithaca, playing in the Modern FNM at the local store the Enchanted Badger. Almost three months later, here I am, about to write about my experience playing in my very first Grand Prix Trial (GPT) this weekend. In fact, I played in two GPT's - one on Saturday and one on Sunday.

THE LEAD-UP

It was around the time that the fall semester started (end of August) that I learned about the then-upcoming GPT's.  At the time, I had been playing in the Modern FNM every week since the end of July, always piloting my mono-white Death & Taxes (D&T) deck. I was enjoying the challenge of playing the deck, improving it, and I was enjoying the Modern format as a whole. It's incredibly diverse, with a plethora of viable strategies (or at least it seemed so at the Badger). Above all else, I was enjoying the competition and enjoying pushing myself to improve.

As such, I was thrilled to hear that there would be GPT's in nearby locations mid-October. Even though I had no idea what a GPT was exactly, I liked the idea of having a bigger, presumably much more competitive event, to aim for. It gave me goals and gave me motivation to prepare for those goals. During the subsequent weeks, I put a fair bit of time and effort into changing, improving and tailoring my deck for the metagame, as well as playtesting online (via Cockatrice) and with friends. A couple of friends that I made from playing at the Badger also wanted to go to the GPT's, so it became a sort of team effort in preparing for the event, which made it all the more awesome (more on this later). Since then, I've learned a lot more about the Modern format, improved as a player in general, as well as a D&T pilot.

THE DECK

Without going into too much detail, the specific decklist that I played is the product of many iterations of change and experimentation. What started as a fairly stock mono-White D&T list slowly found its way to becoming a W/G list, allowing for more options and more individually powerful cards. However, with more options comes more degrees of freedom, and it was not at all clear what combination of green cards would result in an optimized list (Blade Splicer or Loxodon Smiter? What about Voice of Resurgence? Scavenging Ooze?). Not only does the inclusion of a second colour allow the deck to go in multiple different directions, green provides access to powerful non-creature spells as well, including Collected Company and Dromoka's Command.

Below is my decklist for the Saturday GPT:



Although it's not necessary for me to catalogue all of the things I tried along with my observations, there are a couple of inclusions/exclusions that I think are most noteworthy.

When I first added green to the deck, one of the biggest incentives was to play Collected Company (I don't need to go into how nuts this card can be). I ran 2 copies of it, in lieu of Restoration Angel, which was unfortunate since in my opinion Restoration Angel is incredibly strong. Still, CoCo ranged from good to absolutely insane every time I resolved it. It being a slight non-bo with Thalia prevented me from running more of them. However.. on Friday, the night before the first GPT of the weekend, I decided to cut them in place of the original Restoration Angels. My initial reasoning was that despite the raw power of the card, Collected Company offers me very little control over what's happening immediately, whereas in the face of removal Restoration Angel provides the same level of advantage,with more control of your own plays. I also felt that having more fliers would be incredibly helpful.

Removing Collected Company was also somewhat of a necessity in order to accommodate for another card that I felt was incredibly important: Gaddock Teeg. In addition to the comments in the previous paragraph, while Collected Company is incredible, it does little to improve some of the deck's worse matchups. Resolving your own CoCo versus other CoCo decks or Kiki Chord feels mediocre, all of which are very much favoured against D&T. Meanwhile Gaddock Teeg shuts off opposing Collected Company's, Chord of Calling, Splinter Twin, Cryptic Command, Planeswalkers (Tron), etc.

In any case, these changes made room for a few other minor tweaks, all of which result in the list shown above. And the changes were very, very much worth it. The only change I made from Saturday to Sunday was exchanging the Engineered Explosives in the sideboard for an Ethersworn Canonist.

TOURNAMENT REPORT - SATURDAY: GPT SYRACUSE

On Saturday, Daniel, Peter and I drive an hour to a shop called "Play the Game, Read the Story" in Syracuse. It's as about as big as the new 401 Games location in Toronto, spread out on one single floor. There were many aisles of comic books, very neat.

We find an empty table, of which there were plenty (only 14 players showed up for the event), to finalize our decklists and get ready for the event. Before I knew it, I had handed in my list, played a quick practice match against Daniel, sat through the players' meeting, and found myself in my very first GPT match.

Match 1 - Jared - B/W (Deadguy Ale?)

I initially peg him on B/W Tokens, which scares me, as it is a pretty bad matchup for D&T (though having maindeck Scavenging Ooze helps against Lingering Souls). Turns out he is not playing that particular deck. It seemed similar to Deadguy Ale, an archetype that I've gotten glimpses of on the MTG Salvation forums.

Game 1: I'm on the play, keeping a hand that included Aether Vial, two copies of Thalia, Scavenging Ooze, and two Tectonic Edge's (no coloured lands). I lead with my Vial while he leads by searching for a Sword of Light and Shadow with Steelshaper's Gift, followed by a turn 2 Tidehollow Sculler, taking my Scavenging Ooze. I keep my Vial on two, and attack with Thalia. With no blockers, he attacks with his Tidehollow Sculler, to which I respond by Vial'ing in my second Thalia, blowing up the first, but blocking the Sculler to retrieve my Scooze, which I promptly Vial in on my next turn. I manage to pump my creatures a couple of times with Gavony Township, while casting a timely Dromoka's Command to rid him of his Bitterblossom, and beat him down for the win.

Game 2: I keep a hand with no early disruption, opting to keep a hand with Path to Exile. He has plenty of mana while I deploy my board, and surprises me with a Stillmoon Cavalier (which has protection from White, and can be given flying, first strike, and +1/+0). This stops me in my tracks, as my Restoration Angel is no longer able to attack. Fortunately, he cannot afford to attack either, even after dropping a second Stillmoon Cavalier. With a Ghost Quarter in play under my control, he activates his Shambling Vent to bait me into killing it, which I do. He promptly drops a Vault of the Archangel and pass the turn (which would allow him to start attacking me while gaining life). I get incredibly lucky by topdecking a Tectonic Edge, and crack it to get rid of the Vault. Hastily, he responds by activating the Vault. This was a mistake, as he tapped out, thus unable to give his knights flying, allowing me to attack with my Restoration Angel for 7 (Gavony had been activated twice in the board stall, along with double Exalted trigger). This put him low enough that I swung with my entire board for lethal the next turn.

Match 2 - Daniel - Grixis Control

This was unfortunate, as I hoped not to play either of the buddies I came with. Added were the facts that I consider Daniel to be quite a good player. He knew my deck and had tested against me a few times (winning the majority of them). Still, I am generally quite confident in my Grixis matchup (whether it be Twin, Control, or Delver) and was not phased by my opponent. Unfortunately I don't have many notes recorded for this match.

Game 1: I am on the play, which is great. I recall my opening hand having Vial, Voice of Resurgence, Thalia and another 2-drop, which is a great hand in this matchup. I make the mistake of hard-casting my Voice of Resurgence on turn 2 instead of biding my time and Vial'ing in my first creature . I knew he had Spell Snare, which he did not waste on the Voice. However, I passed the turn and he promptly Lightning Bolt'ed the Voice. What I should have done was nothing on turn 2, then Vial in the Voice on Turn 3 and hardcast Thalia to force/bait the Spell Snare. In any case, the combination of hatebears along with the Aether Vial eventually prove enough to win the game.

Game 2: I don't recall what happened this game, but I think he beat me with an early Angler backed up by counterspells and removal.

Game 3: On the play again (which we later agree is a crucial difference-maker in the match-up), I manage to race to victory. The details are again blurry, but a crucial play (at least according to him) involved my Vial'ing in a Flickerwisp to get rid of his Jace for the turn and pressuring his life total.

I felt bad beating my friend - I did not want to prevent either of them from advancing/succeeding. Still, I felt proud that I was able to beat him in a relatively high-stakes match. He (semi) jokingly told me that now that I beat him, I'd better go on to win the whole thing.

Match 3 - Anderson - R/G Tron

Game 1: I start on the play with a reasonably good hand, while it was clear that he was not familiar with the matchup. At one point I had a Tectonic Edge in play, and he cast Karn and targeted the Tectonic Edge, to which I responded by cracking it to blow up one of his Tron lands (I also Vial in a Scooze and grow it once to be able to kill his Karn the next turn). Although this was a total amateur-ish play on his part, the rest of his play was decent, as I'm sure he's a good player. I go on to win this game.

Game 2: I keep a hand with 2 Noble Hierarch's, 2 Leonin Arbiter, a Vial and 2 lands. Unfortunately he assembles Tron naturally and wipes my board with consecutive Pyroclasms. Ugin goes on to win the game for him.

Game 3: Although I don't remember how it started, I do know that I won this game with what I think is one of my proudest sequences of plays. I recall looking at my hand and seeing 2 Flickerwisp's and a Restoration Angel. Without any heavy disruption (e.g. Arbiter, Ghost Quarter, etc), and no other board presence, it looked like he was going to be able to assemble Tron easily - and he knew it. So I went for an aggressive line of play. I hardcast my first Flickerwisp. I figure that he can either spend a turn killing it, or ignore it to search and assemble his Tron lands (at that point he had his second Tron land in his hand, while he played and cast Expedition Map to look for his third). He chooses the latter, playing his second Tron land and searching for the final piece. At this point, he's one turn away from assembling Tron and doing big things.

With his life total at 18, I attack him for 3 with the first Flickerwisp. I then cast Restoration Angel, blinking the Flickerwisp, which then targets the Restoration Angel back. The Resto came back at the end of the turn, blinking the Flickerwisp again, which this time targets one of his Tron lands, effectively removing it for the entirety of his turn. As a result, he spends his turn playing his final Tron piece, but without the full mana to play any of his big spells. Subsequently, on my turn I attack him for 6 in the air, taking him from 15 to 9, followed by my second Flickerwisp on my second main phase. The Flickerwisp trigger targets the Resto, which came back at the end of the turn to blank his Tron assemblage for one more turn. Without it, he again has no plays, and can only pass the turn back to me. I attack for 9 in the air for exactly lethal.

At this point I am 3-0 and I am excited. I couldn't believe how amazing a start I was having. How much longer would my hot streak last?? My friends were real excited for me as well. With the standings posted, my mind raced to the possibility that I could potentially intentionally draw (ID) my way into the single elimination bracket (they were only cutting to top 4). Unfortunately, things were thrown off by the number of people in the event.

Match 4 - Stephen - Kiki Chord

Stephen played his Match 3 beside me, so I knew that he was playing Kiki Chord. It also happened that he and I were at the top of the standings. He offered me the draw and I gladly take it. I knew I wasn't guaranteed the possibility of simply drawing into the top 4, but I was very much terrified of the matchup and was happy to get a point off of the draw rather than suffer a loss.

We play a match for fun and he beats me 2-1 (I snag a free win Game 2 off of Leonin Arbiter and Ghost Quarter).

Match 5 - Nicholas - Grixis Twin

After checking the standings, I deduce that a draw would guarantee me a spot in the top 4, despite my not being at the top anymore. My opponent was confident that his tie-breakers would get him in as well, so he offers me the draw, which I happily take. Unfortunately for him, he did not end up making the cut.

We play 2 games for fun, and it's a 1-1 split.

At this point I am ecstatic. My very first GPT. Heck, my very first Modern tournament bigger than an FNM. I was in top 4! As they announce the top 4, Peter and Daniel are super excited for me, and I cannot help but smile and laugh (on the inside, though, I was losing it). Unfortunately, neither of them made the cut. Daniel joined a BFZ Draft side event, while Peter pulled up a chair to watch me play my rounds.

The top 4 consisted of W/G Death & Taxes (me), R/G Tron, Kiki Chord and Jund.

Top 4 - Abe - R/G Tron

Friendly fellow - introduced me to a game of Mental Magic before the round started. He seemed like the more experienced Tron player from what I overheard of his conversation with Anderson.

I don't have notes, nor do I recall what really happened in the games, but I won 2-0, both games being on the draw. I had a fair bit of disruption via my creatures in the first game, closing out with fliers. In game 2 he tried a different sort of approach, opting to play his coloured lands first to deal with my threats before assembling Tron. I'm not sure how valid this strategy is, but in this instance I don't think it worked out for him. Despite him playing through three copies of Pyroclasm (one of which he used as a 1-for-1) and two Rending Volleys, he was not able to advance his board, while I had enough creatures to beat him for the win.

Holy crap. In the finals?! This is unbelievable!!! I look over to the other table and see that Kiki Chord won over Jund. Welp.

Top 2 - Stephen - Kiki Chord

Even though I am realistically pessimistic about the matchup, I know that my deck is capable of winning against Kiki Chord, so it was just a matter of seeing what would happen. In any case, I offer to split the packs, and play for bye's (first place would get 2 bye's at GP Pittsburgh - is this real life?!). This way, I felt that I would be getting a few more free packs for losing to a miserable matchup.

Game 1: I start the first game on the play, and deploy my creatures while he does the same. Leonin Arbiter and Thalia prevent him from going off with consecutive Chords of Calling, and the board begins to stall out. The single maindeck Gaddock Teeg shows up, and locks him out of playing Chord at all. Still, the game could easily go south for me if he hardcasts Resto and/or Kiki-Jiki. At one point he gets rid of the Gaddock Teeg and Chord's for Eternal Witness, not realizing that I had a Scavenging Ooze in play (he also stated that he had a Scooze of his own and thus thought I did not - maybe my Scavenging Ooze being the Promo foil threw him off). I eventually beat him with an unmanageably big Scavenging Ooze. (Wow, I won game 1 - this is amazing, maybe I can pull it off after all!)

Game 2: This game, he manages to hardcast Kiki-Jiki and proceeds to beat my face in with increasingly bigger and more numerous Elemental tokens.

Game 3: This game went similarly to Game 1, in that I was able to stick multiple hatebears and lock him out of going off via Chord (with Arbiter, Thalia and Gaddock Teeg in play). The board clogs up, and a Scavenging Ooze staredown ensues. With Lightning Helix, he gets rid of Gaddock Teeg, which allows him to start playing the three Chords that were rotting in his hand. He uses the first one to Chord for 2, and I am left wondering if it's a bait (I had Restoration Angel in my hand, which could blink the Leonin Arbiter and prevent him from searching his library), but I figure there are no game-winning threats with 2CMC and let it resolve. I think he gets a Voice of Resurgence. His next Chord is for 1, which also resolves, getting him a Birds of Paradise. Meanwhile, I decide to play my Restoration Angel, which swings for 4 every turn with the help of Noble Hierarch. Meanwhile he is gaining life back off of two Coursers of Kruphix. I think the board state had gotten to the point that he could just attack and outrace me, but it appeared he wanted to go for the combo win (with Kiki in hand and Chord for Resto), but by the time I had him at lethal, he was one mana away from winning on the spot with the combo, thanks to Arbiter + Thalia. We shake hands, and he shakes his head. Granted he made multiple mistakes and didn't play optimally, I did it - I won.

As the head Judge announced the winner, Peter stood up and cheered - he was just as excited as I was! Death & Taxes! First place! My first GPT - I'd won it. Incredible.

[Closing thoughts: DROMOKA COMMAND, RESTO ANGEL, GADDOCK TEEG
LUCK, EVERYTHING COMING TOGETHER]