Sunday, July 26, 2015

[Modern] FNM Part II - Tournament Report

After writing about my recent Modern FNM experience, I resolved to write up a more technical and detailed report of my deck and how I fared throughout the event. This post will be about exactly that, so here I go! If you are interested solely in the tournament report, feel free to scroll down to the bottom of this post.

I already posted my decklist in my previous post, but here it is again:



Big shout-outs to all the folks from the Modern Death & Taxes Primer thread on MTG Salvation who have put in a lot of time into writing up a wonderfully informative primer that gave me the inspiration to build my own version of the deck over a year ago, and who have consistently updated the thread with new insights and innovations. Most of the changes I've made to my deck have come from suggestions made in this thread.

The first iteration of my deck that I originally built was very cookie-cutter, and rough around the edges. It ran four copies of almost everything, including four copies of Aven Mindcensor, Kitchen Finks, Blade Splicer and Restoration Angel. The heavy focus on using blink effects to generate value was lots of fun (not that the deck lacked tech/tools in the first place), but it was very obviously unrefined and not well-equipped to handle a diverse set of matchups.

Since then, I feel like this deck has gone through a good amount of improvement, with some notable inclusions/exclusions that help address particularly important matchups (take it with a grain of salt, since while I have had the deck and have thought about it for a long time, I have relatively little real-life playing experience with it):

Firstly, the current iteration runs four copies of Dryad Militant. I have always had my doubts about just what 1-drops to play in the deck. But Aether Vial is just too good to not take advantage of being able to occasionally flashing in a 1-drop on turn two in addition to playing a 2-drop. I at one point felt like Icatian Javelineers could be quite good, given the various important and powerful 1-toughness creatures in the format (though at present it may be a bit slow and not as impactful as some of the other possible 1-drops). Judge's Familiar is also decent, of which my deck ran 2 copies before this week. But at this point, I feel like Dryad Militant is not only the clear favourite, but is almost a necessity. With the recent rise of Grixis decks and the prevalence of Delve creatures (not to mention the ubiquitous inclusion of Snapcaster Mage and cantrips in blue decks), Dryad Militant provides a 2/1 body with the added bonus of minimizing the size of the opponent's graveyard.

Secondly, the maindeck inclusion of a single copy of Spellskite is very potent. It greatly improves the deck's odds in game 1 against numerous match-ups, the most notable being Splinter Twin, Boggles, and Infect (why wait until game 2 to sideboard them in?). As intuitive as it is, it is by no means my original idea, but ever since I came across it I have been a big fan of it ever since.

Similarly, the miser's Dismember is also a concession to Twin. Other than that, I have since cut the number of Blade Splicers to 3 and Restoration Angels to 2, which moves a little bit more away from having a heavy blink-effect presence in the deck in favor of including the other singletons. Aven Mindcensor is a card that I have been happy to shave to one copy so far. Flashing it in against a fetchland is good, and it has high impact in certain matchups, but its unimpressive body and slightly narrow range of use warrants it coming out of the sideboard more than a heavy maindeck presence.

Brimaz is a house. I am not sure about the rest, partially because I am not entirely familiar with my local store's metagame. But I can see myself adjusting the number of Kitchen Finks, and potentially cutting the Anafenza (it looks like it should be good as a one-of, but so far I have not seen it in action enough). Similar arguments apply for the single Sword of Fire and Ice.

In terms of potential inclusions, I am a bit dubious of Vryn Wingmare, the new non-legendary Thalia with wings, but I am very much open to the possibility that it could be quite good in numerous match-ups. I currently do not have any copies, and only time and testing will show its effectiveness. I am also really impressive with how good Archangel of Tithes looks, particularly against creature-based decks like Elves and Merfolk. I could totally see it being included as a one-of, but that'll have to wait until I actually own a copy.

Lastly, with regards to the sideboard, the one listed above is mostly a result of: 1) the cards (un)available to me (I most probably would have gotten wrecked by Affinity if I came across it), and 2) my lack of familiarity with the metagame at the Enchanted Badger. But I figured it was good enough for a first pass against a fair number of matchups.

As for the tournament report itself, see below:



That's it for today. Until next time - cheers!



Saturday, July 25, 2015

[Modern] FNM Part I - My Experience!

Long time no see! Last I wrote here, I was trying hard to write an elaborate story about how my Standard Neo-Naya-Blitz deck came to be and how it turned out. I even have a rough draft saved. Looking back, the details are no longer important, or relevant - but some of the lessons I learned are! 

In any case, after another hiatus, here I am. After spending the past month and a half keeping a constant eye on Magic: the Gathering, I have finally put myself out there again, playing paper Magic. I have been focusing mostly on the finance aspect of Magic (albeit at a very amateur level), reading daily articles, Reddit, and listening to the occasional podcast. I do enjoy staying up to date with Modern and Legacy (moreso the former than the latter), which is what today's post is all about: my first experience playing Modern here in Ithaca.

I went over to the local store yesterday afternoon, the Enchanted Badger, to play in their Modern FNM event. It's my second time playing Modern at an event (the last time was over a year ago), even though I've had my Death & Taxes deck built for longer than that. Ever since coming across its primer on MTG Salvation, I was fascinated by the intricacies of the deck. For those who don't know the deck, you can check it out here: Modern Death & Taxes Primer. From an appreciation perspective, I like the Legacy version even more, and rightfully so, since that's where this deck originates. Unfortunately I have never been able to get into the Legacy format, since some of the cards are very much out of my financial capacity (I'm looking at you, Rishadan Port and Karakas). I went in rather intimidated, since Modern can be a pretty intense format, and I severely lacked first-hand experience. On the other hand, I have had the deck for a long time, and like to think that I have some knowledge of my deck, how it fares in certain match-ups, and the format in general. In any case, I really looked forward to interacting with the local players and competing!

The decklist I used is as follows:



Without going too much into the details of how I came to the it (I should/would like to write another post about that specific topic), the above list is a slightly more sculpted version of my original build, which had much more four-of's, and focused more on taking advantage of blinking effects. A lot of tweaks were inspired by recent posts from the primer thread linked earlier, as well as a recent deck that made Top 8 at an SCG Invitational Qualifier.

I went 3-1-1 with the deck, and finished 4th overall out of around 30 people. I had a great time, and considering I went in knowing anything was possible, including getting completely destroyed, I was very pleased with the result. Without being too hard on myself, I do feel like I could have done slightly better, though now that I've had a first pass with the deck I'll definitely aim to improve both the deck and my skills. At the same time, I feel like most of the players there were relatively unaware of my deck, which to an extent certainly caught them off guard. (As an aside: I found out after the event that the store did not have any promo Path to Exiles to give out. Needless to say, I couldn't help but feel a bit salty, and gypped of what would have been my prize to bring home.)

The metagame at the store seemed very wide, which I think is great. Every match was a different experience - and that's not just due to the decks I faced. I thoroughly enjoyed all the interactions and exchanges I had with the players there. The decks I faced were (in order of matches): MonoR Burn (2-0), G/b Elves (1-1-1), U/R Delver (2-0), MonoU Tron (2-0), and UWR control (1-2). Other decks that I saw included: Grixis Twin (which I was told was one of the more popular decks there), Naya Burn, 4C Control (not sure if he was running Gifts Ungiven or not), R/B Aggro, Monoblack (with Grave Pact!), B/W Tokens, Soul Sisters, and Boggles. I'm sure there were even more decks there, though apparently the turnout was less than usual so perhaps I did not get to experience Modern FNM at the Enchanted Badger at its fullest (not to mention how different it probably is during the schoolyear).

That's a big boggle if I've ever seen one.
Still, the players were all very friendly and open. I really enjoy looking at people's trade binders, even if there isn't a single trade to be had.

I had a particularly good exchange with the player I lost to in my final match. Josh was his name, and very similar to me, he had a Bachelor's degree in Physics, and is currently working an industry job related to lasers. After our match, we talked for a while about our experiences playing the game, and what kind of decks we like to play and how. According to him, he has been playing the same archetype (UWR) since he started playing Magic - and his mastery of his deck definitely showed. His deck was inherently powerful, flexible, and transformative, with the ability to play offensively with Geist of Saint Traft, or switch into a slow grindy control deck with Ajani Vengeant and Keranos. In fact, I learned very tangible lessons about making careful and efficient plays from my games against him.

For example, in our first game, he played a turn 1 fetchland, and I followed up with a turn 1 Dryad Militant. I absolutely expected him to crack the fetchland and put a shockland into play tapped - that would have been my instinctive play. Instead, he took 2 damage to put his Sacred Foundry into play untapped, and Lightning Bolt'ed my Dryad at the end of my turn. It was an aggressive play, or maybe the right word is "proactive", but I was honestly surprised. He later explained that it was the most efficient use of his mana: he had other cards that he wanted to leave mana up for on turn 2. Moreover, given that, if he didn't bolt it then, I would have gotten in for 2 damage anyway. It was just an efficient play.

A second time he caught me off guard was in our third game. I was on the draw after winning game 2, and played a turn 1 Dryad Militant into a turn 2 Thalia. On turn 3 I attacked with both, and he flashed in Snapcaster Mage and promptly traded with the Dryad without flashbacking anything. I'm not sure I would have made that play. But his explanation made a lot of sense to me - at the time, he didn't have any removal spells in his hand, and keeping the Snapcaster Mage in his hand in an effort to wait for an eventual removal spell would have cost him valuable life points, not to mention that the Snapcaster Mage would be a dead card during that time. Instead, by making the trade, the Snapcaster was his removal spell.

Both of these examples were of small plays that made a huge impact on the outcome of their respective games. While I would've greatly enjoyed winning the match, I think leaving with memorable and valuable lessons is definitely better. (Though as an excuse, I also mulliganed to five, which made for an anti-climactic final game of the night. Oh well!) And that is not to say that I only learned from the final match. Every match was a learning experience, and I'm very grateful - I will hopefully write about those in the near future.

All in all, I had a great time playing a format I enjoy at the local store. This will definitely continue, and I will do my best to write about them.

Cheers!
Zimu