After writing about my recent Modern FNM experience, I resolved to write up a more technical and detailed report of my deck and how I fared throughout the event. This post will be about exactly that, so here I go! If you are interested solely in the tournament report, feel free to scroll down to the bottom of this post.
I already posted my decklist in my previous post, but here it is again:
Big shout-outs to all the folks from the Modern Death & Taxes Primer thread on MTG Salvation who have put in a lot of time into writing up a wonderfully informative primer that gave me the inspiration to build my own version of the deck over a year ago, and who have consistently updated the thread with new insights and innovations. Most of the changes I've made to my deck have come from suggestions made in this thread.
The first iteration of my deck that I originally built was very cookie-cutter, and rough around the edges. It ran four copies of almost everything, including four copies of Aven Mindcensor, Kitchen Finks, Blade Splicer and Restoration Angel. The heavy focus on using blink effects to generate value was lots of fun (not that the deck lacked tech/tools in the first place), but it was very obviously unrefined and not well-equipped to handle a diverse set of matchups.
Since then, I feel like this deck has gone through a good amount of improvement, with some notable inclusions/exclusions that help address particularly important matchups (take it with a grain of salt, since while I have had the deck and have thought about it for a long time, I have relatively little real-life playing experience with it):
Firstly, the current iteration runs four copies of Dryad Militant. I have always had my doubts about just what 1-drops to play in the deck. But Aether Vial is just too good to not take advantage of being able to occasionally flashing in a 1-drop on turn two in addition to playing a 2-drop. I at one point felt like Icatian Javelineers could be quite good, given the various important and powerful 1-toughness creatures in the format (though at present it may be a bit slow and not as impactful as some of the other possible 1-drops). Judge's Familiar is also decent, of which my deck ran 2 copies before this week. But at this point, I feel like Dryad Militant is not only the clear favourite, but is almost a necessity. With the recent rise of Grixis decks and the prevalence of Delve creatures (not to mention the ubiquitous inclusion of Snapcaster Mage and cantrips in blue decks), Dryad Militant provides a 2/1 body with the added bonus of minimizing the size of the opponent's graveyard.
Secondly, the maindeck inclusion of a single copy of Spellskite is very potent. It greatly improves the deck's odds in game 1 against numerous match-ups, the most notable being Splinter Twin, Boggles, and Infect (why wait until game 2 to sideboard them in?). As intuitive as it is, it is by no means my original idea, but ever since I came across it I have been a big fan of it ever since.
Similarly, the miser's Dismember is also a concession to Twin. Other than that, I have since cut the number of Blade Splicers to 3 and Restoration Angels to 2, which moves a little bit more away from having a heavy blink-effect presence in the deck in favor of including the other singletons. Aven Mindcensor is a card that I have been happy to shave to one copy so far. Flashing it in against a fetchland is good, and it has high impact in certain matchups, but its unimpressive body and slightly narrow range of use warrants it coming out of the sideboard more than a heavy maindeck presence.
Brimaz is a house. I am not sure about the rest, partially because I am not entirely familiar with my local store's metagame. But I can see myself adjusting the number of Kitchen Finks, and potentially cutting the Anafenza (it looks like it should be good as a one-of, but so far I have not seen it in action enough). Similar arguments apply for the single Sword of Fire and Ice.
In terms of potential inclusions, I am a bit dubious of Vryn Wingmare, the new non-legendary Thalia with wings, but I am very much open to the possibility that it could be quite good in numerous match-ups. I currently do not have any copies, and only time and testing will show its effectiveness. I am also really impressive with how good Archangel of Tithes looks, particularly against creature-based decks like Elves and Merfolk. I could totally see it being included as a one-of, but that'll have to wait until I actually own a copy.
Lastly, with regards to the sideboard, the one listed above is mostly a result of: 1) the cards (un)available to me (I most probably would have gotten wrecked by Affinity if I came across it), and 2) my lack of familiarity with the metagame at the Enchanted Badger. But I figured it was good enough for a first pass against a fair number of matchups.
As for the tournament report itself, see below:
Tournament Report
Match 1 - vs. Carson, playing MonoR Burn
Game 1
I was on the draw, keeping a hand with one land and Aether Vial while he mulliganed to six. Thankfully I did not see any Eidolons of the Great Revel (throughout the match in fact). With burn spells, a Vexing Devil (which I took 4 for, since I did not have any creatures in play) and an Ash Zealot, he put me down to 4 before I played a Kitchen Finks, which I proceeded to blink multiple times with Flickerwisps to put the game out of reach for him.
[1-0]
Game 2
On the draw again, my opening hand included Vial, Thalia, Finks and Flickerwisp. Largely the same story as game 1 (I sideboarded in three copies of Kor Firewalker, but never saw any), but once I landed my Kitchen Finks and got multiple iterations of lifegain, the game was soon over.
[2-0]
Match 2 - vs. Daniel, playing G/b Elves
Game 1
I was on the play. I came in knowing that Elves posed a tough match-up for my deck. Moreover, I was very unfamiliar with Modern Elves, thinking that it included Green Sun's Zenith (d'oh) and that it was much more combo-oriented. As a result, I dismembered the very first Nettle Sentinel I saw at the cost of 4 life points, which was a huge misplay, as he beat my face in with numerous elves including three Elvish Archdruids.
[0-1]
Game 2
On the play, after sideboarding in three copies of Mirran Crusader, I stuck one on turn 3 and never looked back. Tectonic Edge threatening to blow up his Nykthos if he ever reached 4 lands put a fair bit of pressure on him.
[1-1]
Game 3
Both of us played slowly in the first two games, which left us with barely over five minutes for this last match. As a result, I played at a frantic pace, which ultimately would cost me big time. Though I had a Vial, I was stuck on one Plains (and some Ghost Quarters/Tectonic Edges) for a good while, which prevented me from hardcasting my 3-drops to increase my board presence. My first misplay of the game came when I blinked in a Mirran Crusader instead of Brimaz. I was already on the back-foot, and he was looking to race me with a handful of 1/1's and 2/2's. There was no way I was in a position to go on the offensive with the Crusader. This was not such a big deal though, as I got the Crusader down the subsequent turn, which stabilized me a great deal. At some point, we run out of time and go to turns. And this is where I make the most crucial misplay of the evening.
Momentarily forgetting the lessons I learned from Mike Flores's famous article about "Who's the beatdown?" (which I've read multiple times in my life), I very hastily attack with my Brimaz, which has vigilance, but not my Mirran Crusader (which would have dealt 4 points of damage), instinctively thinking that I still needed to defend, not realizing that with only 4 turns remaining, I was the one on the offensive, not him. In poetic fashion, the game comes to a draw with him at 3 life. I spent the next ten minutes mentally kicking myself for my crucial misplay. In retrospect, I did not realize that once we went to turns, I no longer needed to play at as brisk a pace, since we were no longer limited by time, but by turns. This is something I need to work on, identifying key moments that require me to slow down and bit and think more thoroughly about the state of the game.
[1-1-1]
Match 3 - vs. Cole, playing R/U Delver
Game 1
On the play, I keep a hand with Vial while he mulligans to 6. He plays a turn-1 Monastery Swiftspear, which chips away at my life total. But with my Vial, I play more threats than he can handle (partially because he had multiple copies of Vapor Snag instead of burn spells, which does not fare well against an active Aether Vial) and run away with the game. It also becomes apparent that his deck is a budget version.
[1-0]
Game 2
I don't have a lot of notes about this game, other than that I was on the draw. I recall that he played an early Delver that he wasn't able to protect, while again I had more threats than he could deal with.
[2-0]
Match 4 - vs. Sam (Cole's little brother), playing MonoU Tron
Game 1
On the draw, I manage to play 2 copies of Ghost Quarter and a Tectonic Edge in the first four or five turns. I was able to consistently keep him off Tron while he did not seem to have any answers or threats of his own and the game ended in short order.
[1-0]
Game 2
This time he assembled his Tron lands on turn 3, but did not have anything to cast with it (he also did not have blue mana as a result). I manage to beat him down to 4 life with some threats, including a Thalia and Leonin Arbiter (for which he had plenty of mana to pay the search fee), before he played two Wurmcoil Engines in one turn! I had 2 copies of Path to Exile in my hand, but only 1 source of white mana (and 2 other lands) - if he managed to deal any combat damage with either Wurmcoil, the game was most definitely lost. Thankfully, I topdecked the perfect card - a Plains, and proceeded to Path both his Wurmcoils and swing in for just enough to kill him.
[2-0]
Match 5 - vs. Josh, playing UWR Control
Game 1
Before the match started, I learned that he had not lost a single game. Hopefully I could change that. On the draw, I keep a hand I thought was decent at the time, which included Dryad Militant as a turn-1 play (but lacked Aether Vial). This was a tough match-up, especially on the draw. He opened with a hand that included Lightning Bolt, Path to Exile, Remand, and Snapcaster Mage. He then proceeded to win the game very handily with a Geist of Saint Traft.
[0-1]
Game 2
After Game 1 we talked a bit about the matchup, and that the ideal scenario for me would be to be on the play and open with a Thalia or Arbiter and attack his manabase. And that was exactly what happened. Turn 1 Dryad Militant, turn 2 Thalia, into turn 3 Arbiter and Ghost Quartering one of his lands put me way out ahead and I won the game very quickly.
[1-1]
Game 3
Not the climactic game 3 I was looking forward to, since I mulliganed to five on the draw. He was in the driver's seat right from the beginning, and had transformed his deck into a full-out control deck with his sideboard. In addition to counterspells, burn, and Snapcasters, he played Timely Reinforcements, Ajani Vengeant and topped it off with a Keranos to seal the deal.
[1-2]
Summary: 3-1-1, 4th overall
Overall I was happy with my performance. I was aware of my misplays, and learned a lot of valuable lessons. It was a great time, and I really look forward to using my experiences and lessons to improve my game. Unfortunately, it turned out they did not have any promo Path to Exiles to give out, which left me feeling disappointed.
No comments:
Post a Comment